Review: 'Brooklyn Castle' (Moving Look At Trials & Triumphs Of A Junior High School's Chess Team)
Photo Credit: S & A

Review: 'Brooklyn Castle' (Moving Look At Trials & Triumphs Of A Junior High School's Chess Team)


Brooklyn Castle (directed by Katie Dallamaggiore) is a documentary about I.S. 318, an inner-city public school that's home to the most-winning junior high school chess team in the country. But a series of deep public school budget cuts now threaten to undermine its hard-won success.

An absolutely wonderfully-produced feature documentary filled with touching, inspirational stories of hope, ambition and perseverance.

In a climate in which "escape" film narratives of youth from working class families and under-represented groups – in this case, specifically black and Latino kids – are dominated by stories in which athletic ability is option number 1 as a means for that escape from socio-economic oppression, the intellectual tension-filled drama that plays out in Brooklyn Castle is most refreshing.

I was moved by the individual narratives of these pre-teen and teenage boys and girls from I.S. 318 (an inner-city school where an overwhelming number of students are from homes with incomes below the federal poverty level) who've invested and sacrificed so, so much to master their chess skills (some of them would rank above Albert Einstein if he were to join the school’s competition team), that you simply can't help but root for them to succeed and reach their individual goals, that range from just simply getting into good colleges in the short term, to running for president in the long term.

And you are absolutely convinced that they can and will achieve those aims, if only based on the academic aptitudes, confidence and conviction on display here from each.

Their parents, who've recognized, nourished and also sacrificed for their childrens' talents, are to be commended here as well for what should be obvious reasons.

4 years in the making, there's a broader narrative in Brooklyn Castle, and that is the economic crises which led to unprecedented public school budget cuts that jeopardize primary school education, and, specifically, the after-school programs like that which is at the center of Brooklyn Castle's tale, and how the potential absence of that necessary funding could drastically affect the lives of the children who rely so heavily on them for sustenance.

Watching the film’s 5 stars – 1 who possesses a natural gift for chess and at just 11 years old (Justus), has been selected to join the US Chess Federation’s All-American team; and another, the sole girl in the group (Rochelle), who’s on her way to becoming the first African American female chess master in the history of the game at just 13 years old – handle immense pressure (the kind of pressure that men and women decades older would likely be crushed under) and thrive, is exhilarating and inspiring.

They’re practically forced to mature much sooner than their peers, and, in my humble opinion, will likely go on to become leaders of tomorrow.

But they’re still very much children, and the wounds of a loss sting as it only could for a child; while the thrill of a win is felt just as deeply, except tears are replaced with magnificent, infectious smiles, which only reinforces for the audience the importance of I.S. 318’s after-school chess program, and others like it – vital for not only the students, but for the schools.

As announced earlier this year, Sony Pictures and producer Scott Rudin (Searching For Bobby Fischer) purchased the remake rights to Brooklyn Castle, a documentary that premiered at SXSW this year, where it won the audience award for best documentary.

But before that scripted remake happens, you just might be able to see it at a theater near you, because the film will be released by indie distributor Producers Distribution Agency (part of Cinetic Media), starting this Friday, October 19.

Watch the trailer below:


Shadow and Act is a website dedicated to cinema, television and web content of Africa and its global Diaspora. With daily news, interviews, in-depth investigations into the audiovisual industry, and more, Shadow and Act promotes content created by and about people of African descent throughout the world.

© 2023 Shadow & Act. All rights reserved.